Skip to corpus content
HIMR Public Corpustimestamped source index

Recording

why I HATE Baldur's Gate 3

2023-08-17 · 6 min

internet_archive
Machine transcript · wording, timing and speaker attribution may be wrong

Wording, speaker labels, and timestamps can still be wrong. A transcript does not establish that statements in the recording are factual. Use the source links and surrounding context.

Read summary

Expand to load the summary.

Open summary page ↗
Source information & transcript revisions

Transcript revisions

  1. rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158bMachine-generated and unreviewed; may be wrong; not a verified quotation.
    enraw_asractive167 segments

Transcript

en
  1. I made a pretty scathing and critical

    Segment details0:00–0:03 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_0
  2. review of Baldur's Gate 3 a couple weeks

    Segment details0:03–0:05 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_1
  3. ago, and it's been a few weeks since I

    Segment details0:06–0:08 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_2
  4. released my review, and it seems like

    Segment details0:08–0:09 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_3
  5. basically the entire internet disagrees

    Segment details0:09–0:11 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_4
  6. with me. And it seems like the game is

    Segment details0:11–0:13 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_5
  7. extremely popular, it's getting all of

    Segment details0:13–0:15 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_6
  8. these awards, and it's beating other games

    Segment details0:15–0:17 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_7
  9. in terms of viewership on Twitch and stuff

    Segment details0:17–0:19 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_8
  10. like that. And I just, I really don't

    Segment details0:19–0:21 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_9
  11. understand why this game is so popular.

    Segment details0:21–0:23 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_10
  12. It— when I played the game, I just felt

    Segment details0:23–0:26 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_11
  13. incredibly bored, and I felt like this

    Segment details0:26–0:27 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_12
  14. game has absolutely nothing interesting or

    Segment details0:28–0:30 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_13
  15. unique about it. I still stand by my

    Segment details0:31–0:32 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_14
  16. points, and I still think it's one of the

    Segment details0:33–0:34 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_15
  17. most boring games I've ever played in the

    Segment details0:34–0:36 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_16
  18. last few years. Basically, it's just like

    Segment details0:36–0:38 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_17
  19. a turn-based role-playing game where you

    Segment details0:39–0:41 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_18
  20. got a lot of stats and you level up your

    Segment details0:41–0:43 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_19
  21. character and you get gear. I mean,

    Segment details0:43–0:45 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_20
  22. that's like basically every single

    Segment details0:45–0:47 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_21
  23. role-playing game that's ever existed.

    Segment details0:47–0:48 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_22
  24. And exactly what does Baldur's Gate 3 do

    Segment details0:49–0:51 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_23
  25. that is so mind-blowingly amazing? I just

    Segment details0:51–0:54 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_24
  26. do not understand it. I think one of the

    Segment details0:54–0:56 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_25
  27. main appealing parts of Baldur's Gate 3 is

    Segment details0:56–0:59 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_26
  28. how there's like multiple dialogue options

    Segment details0:59–1:01 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_27
  29. and you can like choose the destiny or the

    Segment details1:01–1:04 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_28
  30. future of your character, and there's

    Segment details1:05–1:06 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_29
  31. different paths and ways you can develop

    Segment details1:06–1:09 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_30
  32. your character depending on which

    Segment details1:10–1:11 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_31
  33. characters you talk to and which ones you

    Segment details1:11–1:13 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_32
  34. help or which ones you don't help. And I

    Segment details1:13–1:15 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_33
  35. don't really feel like this is a unique

    Segment details1:15–1:16 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_34
  36. selling point either. There's loads of

    Segment details1:17–1:18 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_35
  37. role-playing games where you've got

    Segment details1:18–1:20 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_36
  38. multiple choice and multiple endings.

    Segment details1:20–1:22 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_37
  39. This is nothing new, so I really don't

    Segment details1:22–1:23 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_38
  40. know why Baldur's Gate 3 is getting so

    Segment details1:24–1:26 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_39
  41. much hype and so many people are praising

    Segment details1:26–1:27 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_40
  42. it. When I played it It was like a very

    Segment details1:27–1:30 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_41
  43. dumbed-down version of like some kind of

    Segment details1:30–1:33 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_42
  44. role-playing game, but it's turn-based and

    Segment details1:33–1:35 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_43
  45. you've got attacks and different abilities

    Segment details1:35–1:37 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_44
  46. and you level up, you've got attribute

    Segment details1:37–1:39 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_45
  47. points. This is so bog standard and

    Segment details1:39–1:41 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_46
  48. nothing new. The graphics were not even

    Segment details1:41–1:43 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_47
  49. that good. They were okay for 2023, but

    Segment details1:43–1:46 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_48
  50. they weren't very impressive. And then

    Segment details1:47–1:48 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_49
  51. because of the far-up camera with the

    Segment details1:48–1:50 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_50
  52. top-down view, you can barely even see

    Segment details1:51–1:52 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_51
  53. your character anyway. So you spend all

    Segment details1:52–1:53 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_52
  54. this time customizing your character and

    Segment details1:54–1:56 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_53
  55. all you ever see is like the top of the

    Segment details1:56–1:57 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_54
  56. heads. And the level design was really

    Segment details1:57–1:59 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_55
  57. rubbish and I kept getting lost and stuck

    Segment details1:59–2:01 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_56
  58. on the map and I couldn't tell where I was

    Segment details2:01–2:03 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_57
  59. supposed to go because they don't really

    Segment details2:03–2:04 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_58
  60. make it very clear. And the maps and the

    Segment details2:05–2:06 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_59
  61. environments just look kind of boring as

    Segment details2:07–2:08 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_60
  62. well. Everything about the game just

    Segment details2:08–2:10 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_61
  63. incredibly bored me so much that I

    Segment details2:11–2:14 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_62
  64. couldn't play it for longer than a few

    Segment details2:14–2:15 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_63
  65. hours. And don't get me wrong, I love

    Segment details2:16–2:17 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_64
  66. turn-based games. I probably love

    Segment details2:17–2:18 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_65
  67. turn-based games like Darkest Dungeon. I

    Segment details2:18–2:20 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_66
  68. really love that game, it was so good. I

    Segment details2:20–2:22 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_67
  69. played it loads of times. I spent more

    Segment details2:23–2:25 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_68
  70. than a few hours— I spent like weeks and

    Segment details2:26–2:27 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_69
  71. weeks playing that game, completely

    Segment details2:28–2:29 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_70
  72. hooked. And I was trying out all of the

    Segment details2:29–2:30 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_71
  73. different classes. I named my characters,

    Segment details2:31–2:32 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_72
  74. actually felt kind kind of sad when some

    Segment details2:32–2:34 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_73
  75. of my characters died. And the game is

    Segment details2:34–2:36 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_74
  76. really challenging and exciting, and that

    Segment details2:36–2:38 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_75
  77. was really fun. And I also liked XCOM. I

    Segment details2:39–2:41 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_76
  78. played a lot of XCOM 1, which is also a

    Segment details2:41–2:43 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_77
  79. turn-based tactical shooting game, and I

    Segment details2:43–2:45 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_78
  80. really enjoyed that and customizing my

    Segment details2:46–2:47 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_79
  81. character and leveling up and getting more

    Segment details2:47–2:49 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_80
  82. powerful. So I do enjoy turn-based games

    Segment details2:50–2:52 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_81
  83. when it's a good game like those ones I

    Segment details2:53–2:54 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_82
  84. mentioned. But when I played Baldur's Gate

    Segment details2:55–2:56 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_83
  85. 3, I don't know why I couldn't get into

    Segment details2:57–2:58 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_84
  86. it, because it's not that I hate

    Segment details2:58–2:59 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_85
  87. turn-based games— I like some— but I just

    Segment details3:00–3:01 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_86
  88. couldn't get into the game even though I

    Segment details3:02–3:03 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_87
  89. like fantasy RPG games. I loved Elden Ring

    Segment details3:03–3:06 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_88
  90. and Diablo 3. They're kind of like fantasy

    Segment details3:06–3:08 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_89
  91. RPG games in the same way Baldur's Gate 3

    Segment details3:09–3:10 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_90
  92. is, but the combat mechanics are obviously

    Segment details3:11–3:13 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_91
  93. different. But with Baldur's Gate 3, I

    Segment details3:13–3:15 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_92
  94. don't know why, I just, I couldn't get

    Segment details3:16–3:17 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_93
  95. into it. It was just kind of weird. It's

    Segment details3:18–3:20 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_94
  96. kind of strange because the game just

    Segment details3:20–3:21 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_95
  97. feels kind of janky and unpolished. It

    Segment details3:22–3:24 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_96
  98. feels kind of like an indie game, like

    Segment details3:24–3:27 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_97
  99. maybe very passionate game lovers made it

    Segment details3:27–3:29 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_98
  100. in their mum's bedroom or in their

    Segment details3:30–3:31 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_99
  101. basement when they're studying at

    Segment details3:32–3:33 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_100
  102. university, and it's like a passion

    Segment details3:33–3:34 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_101
  103. project. But I don't really feel like it's

    Segment details3:34–3:35 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_102
  104. a AAA game with very high polish, even

    Segment details3:35–3:38 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_103
  105. though the— I think the game's been in

    Segment details3:39–3:40 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_104
  106. early access for years now. And even

    Segment details3:40–3:43 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_105
  107. though it's been in early access for years

    Segment details3:43–3:45 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_106
  108. and it's finally like the proper public

    Segment details3:45–3:47 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_107
  109. version that's been released, it just

    Segment details3:47–3:48 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_108
  110. didn't feel good. The gameplay, moving the

    Segment details3:49–3:51 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_109
  111. character around didn't feel good. The

    Segment details3:52–3:53 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_110
  112. gameplay didn't feel good. I just didn't

    Segment details3:53–3:55 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_111
  113. really feel good with the UI or the menu

    Segment details3:55–3:56 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_112
  114. system or the inventory system. The entire

    Segment details3:57–3:58 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_113
  115. game just felt kind of unpolished to me

    Segment details3:59–4:01 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_114
  116. personally. And also I didn't really find

    Segment details4:01–4:02 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_115
  117. the romance part of the game to be very

    Segment details4:03–4:05 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_116
  118. amusing. I know a lot of people think it's

    Segment details4:05–4:06 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_117
  119. funny, like a big lizard man falling in

    Segment details4:07–4:09 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_118
  120. love with a little tiny dwarf woman, or

    Segment details4:09–4:11 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_119
  121. like a little dwarf guy falling in love

    Segment details4:11–4:13 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_120
  122. with a big hot elf lady.

    Segment details4:13–4:15 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_121
  123. That's— yeah, I guess it's funny if you've

    Segment details4:16–4:19 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_122
  124. got the mentality or the sense of humor of

    Segment details4:19–4:21 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_123
  125. like a 12-year-old, but as a grown man, I

    Segment details4:21–4:23 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_124
  126. didn't really find the romance stuff very

    Segment details4:23–4:25 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_125
  127. interesting because number one, I don't

    Segment details4:26–4:27 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_126
  128. really want to get aroused. I don't want

    Segment details4:28–4:29 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_127
  129. to be playing a video game and then get

    Segment details4:29–4:30 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_128
  130. turned on at the idea of like a wood elf

    Segment details4:31–4:32 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_129
  131. and a dwarf doing it in the forest. I just

    Segment details4:33–4:35 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_130
  132. kind of want to play game and have fun and

    Segment details4:35–4:37 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_131
  133. get hooked on its gameplay mechanics,

    Segment details4:37–4:38 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_132
  134. not, um, you know, have my man drive

    Segment details4:39–4:41 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_133
  135. activated. So I was tempted to buy the

    Segment details4:41–4:43 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_134
  136. game again because I bought it the first

    Segment details4:44–4:44 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_135
  137. time, then I refunded it because it was so

    Segment details4:45–4:46 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_136
  138. boring. I was kind of tempted to buy it

    Segment details4:46–4:49 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_137
  139. again and try it again since it seems to

    Segment details4:49–4:51 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_138
  140. be getting so much praise and everyone

    Segment details4:51–4:53 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_139
  141. seems to love it, and they're saying, oh,

    Segment details4:53–4:54 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_140
  142. it's like the next best thing to Diablo

    Segment details4:54–4:57 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_141
  143. and Elden Ring. But I just don't really

    Segment details4:58–4:59 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_142
  144. see myself enjoying it. And if I buy it

    Segment details4:59–5:01 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_143
  145. again, then obviously I can't refund it

    Segment details5:02–5:03 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_144
  146. again, and then I would have just wasted

    Segment details5:03–5:05 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_145
  147. like £50, which I don't really want to do.

    Segment details5:05–5:07 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_146
  148. I would like to save my money if I could

    Segment details5:07–5:09 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_147
  149. feel confident that I would really enjoy

    Segment details5:09–5:11 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_148
  150. the game, then yes, I would buy it again.

    Segment details5:11–5:13 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_149
  151. But I've been watching videos and it's so

    Segment details5:13–5:16 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_150
  152. boring. I mean, it's boring to play and

    Segment details5:16–5:18 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_151
  153. it's boring to watch. I just don't really

    Segment details5:18–5:20 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_152
  154. see what is so great about this game. So

    Segment details5:21–5:22 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_153
  155. unfortunately, I'm gonna stick with what I

    Segment details5:22–5:25 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_154
  156. said in my review and keep the score I

    Segment details5:26–5:27 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_155
  157. gave it. I think I gave it like 6.2 out of

    Segment details5:27–5:29 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_156
  158. 10, which I think is fair enough for the

    Segment details5:30–5:31 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_157
  159. game. I really don't think it's a great

    Segment details5:32–5:33 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_158
  160. game. I don't think it should win any

    Segment details5:34–5:35 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_159
  161. awards, and I don't know why it's smashing

    Segment details5:35–5:37 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_160
  162. milestones like, oh, the most number of

    Segment details5:37–5:40 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_161
  163. viewers, players playing it at the same

    Segment details5:40–5:42 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_162
  164. time, concurrent playership. I just don't

    Segment details5:42–5:44 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_163
  165. understand what all this hype is around

    Segment details5:44–5:46 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_164
  166. it, and it's just kind of a boring,

    Segment details5:46–5:48 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_165
  167. bland, and lacking in luster kind of game.

    Segment details5:48–5:51 · rev_552a47f223884b700ffa2df84621158b_166